On mental hospital patients should be mandatory, has long been debated. In the interview process a number of experts found that the academic and legal circles in the mental, the rights of mental patients there is a big controversy. Psychiatry that mental illness can not properly express their own consciousness, and thus force the hospital is a means of protecting them. France and academic experts believe that mandatory medical deprived of personal freedom of patients and should be used with caution.
Sun Dongdong, Peking University, director of forensic, mainly in terms of forensic psychiatry, he executed prisoners every year to do justice to give a lot of identification of mental illness.
Sun Dongdong: the mental patient to the hospital is the best protection
a considerable number of mental patients, they do not involve psychotic symptoms, others are normal. Specialized households on the old petition, I responsibly say that it does not say 100%, at least 99% of mental problems - is paranoid disorder
China Newsweek: In the treatment of mental patients, compulsory mental health care for which patients? Applicability how much?
Sun Dongdong: the involuntary hospitalization of mental patients, broadly speaking can be referred to as mandatory health care. Strictly speaking, involuntary admission is limited to the implementation of harm in his behavior, through the statutory identification procedures, found that he was not criminally responsible. This part of the medical care people should be carried out. Mental patients are now basically a non-voluntary hospitalization, even if the foreign law is written in the voluntary hospital, but actually empty talk. Because mental illness does not recognize his sickness he could not go himself to the hospital. If he can he go to the hospital, it is not a severe mental illness.
China News Weekly: In recent years there have been many are forced to live in a mental hospital from the normal case, such as the recent case Zou Yijun, there has been new progress, for she is stimulated,cheap UGG boots, after discharge from psychiatric hospital a monk. How do these cases the attitude you hold?
Sun Dongdong: Zou Yi are the specific circumstances of this case I do not know, not to make improper comments. In real life, the families that their loved ones if the behavior is not normal, more strange, can not live a normal life, that he had mental problems and sent him to a mental hospital to treatment,UGG boots clearance, what is wrong with that? This is an appendicitis patient to the hospital to operate on different? ! If families do not, government does not send mental patients to live on the streets. This is the spirit of the patient's interest in maintaining it?
China Newsweek: But these people look normal, including some petitioners. They are not mentally ill,UGG boots cheap, thinking very clearly. Will force these people to go to a mental hospital, right?
Sun Dongdong: This is because people have a misconception of mental illness. We think that the kind of crazy trouble playing crazy unkempt, and is mentally ill. But in fact quite a number of mental patients, they do not involve psychotic symptoms, others are normal. Specialized households on the old petition, I responsibly say that it does not say 100%, at least 99% of mental problems - mental disorders are paranoid.
China News Weekly: these people need to force it?
Sun Dongdong: paranoid mental disorders that require mandatory category. Because it disturbs the social order. He maintained his one point of view, this view is the mental delusions. In order to achieve a delusion that they can be left their homes at all costs petition. You can go to investigate those who are paranoid petition. He actually reflect the issue resolved, or even no problem. But he endless trouble, how do you explain him not into. So public opinion started to concern the rights of these people is not lack of security, which is in fact the lack of basic mental health knowledge. This situation not only in China, the world has any country, is that governments headaches.
such a case occurred in Shaanxi. An old woman, 60 years from the last century began to petition. Because her husband work in the mine, died of lung cancer. She finds that her husband was injured. Identification of the labor department so her husband died of natural disease. But she does not believe, repeated petitions repeated trouble, has been 60 years from the last century was referred to the beginning of this century.
the last unit and is no way her daughter, sent her to the local mental health center, a diagnosis of paranoid disorder. 38 days hospital stay. The son of her work in Guangdong does not endorse, bring her back, then two people to hospital, unit, daughter to court. Finally, the court unit, the hospital is at fault. This is typical of the judge's lack of knowledge of psychiatry, created with the injustice, is absolutely unjust. Cases like this also occurred in other provinces. And led to serious consequences.
China News Weekly: In reality we see, except for public security mental hospital shelter outside the mandatory medical mental patients, civil psychiatric hospital system and the health system is also hosting the spirit of compulsory medical patients.
Sun Dongdong: public security system have a special psychiatric hospital. Strictly speaking, the public security system is designed to mental hospital mental patients admitted to accident Zhaohuo, while the health system and civil system can not receive compulsory treatment of psychiatric patients.
public security organs to force mental patients admitted to the medical, public security organs only the intervention of other agencies and organizations are not able to intervene, it is
but not the public security system if the local mental hospital, the health system can only be received. As long as government approval, receive mandatory medical psychiatric patients, there is no problem, there is the law. Public security organs of the mental hospital is now only 23, the public security organs shelter need compulsory treatment of mental patients, but not the local public security organs mental hospital, then of course the health system can only be sent to a mental hospital or go to the Home system, because can not let These people living on the streets, creating new hazards.
China News Weekly: forced medical treatment for these mental patients need, how to protect his human rights? Sun Dongdong: took him to the hospital is the best protection. He harmful to society, is also a hazard to himself. We put him up for treatment, to promote his mental recovery. This is the protection of his human rights.
normal people are forced into a mental hospital the frequent occurrence of food for thought
force sent to a mental hospital by their families before, once has a waist-long hair Zou Yijun
be forced off the days in a psychiatric hospital to Zou Yijun painful
now has been a monk for the Zou Yijun Nigeria , filed past many
also calm a woman's individual, Zou should have
this day, she as usual for the newspaper, and say hello and then leave the building security. Zou Jianxiong her brother get the car together to the cemetery as Baoshan grave of the father passed away a year. She did not expect to in the cemetery gate, she was pushed by another seven or eight men in a van, they handcuffed her and forced to take off her pants, the needle bar to her cold. Brother did not save her.
stigma and limp weakness, she felt that he was kidnapped. Her eyes were covered with a thin old tie. When she woke up around me several people wearing white clothes, the girl's head with a nurse hat, many people walked up and down, around seems to be no way out, either a security guard of the glass security doors, either a large sign:
She was taken to a psychiatric hospital.
At 9:00 on March 2, 2009, with a lawsuit directed at mental hospitals in Guangzhou Baiyun People's Court. Zou plaintiff should have, she has been a monk for Nepal, Buddhist name The defendant is the Guangzhou Baiyun Mental Hospital, Zhongshan Hospital and lake ports Zou Yijun family.
in court, Zou statement should have past experience calm face, as if saying someone else's story:
She had a 6 people, parents, two sisters, one brother, well off. Lung cancer in 2005 after his father, the family into chaos.
their home is a traditional Hakka, as a father, joyous, hurried to her description of the object and got married. However, one month after the marriage with the death of his father in name only. After a long conflict and agreement with her ex-husband for divorce, access to 30 million compensation. Followed the outbreak of conflict, according to Zou should have to say, the mother is a patriarchal feudal parents, to seize her 30 million. So the family conspire to bring her to an asylum.
hear the sound of the wind, her friend and lawyer Huang Xuetao with the license agreement was signed, requiring that their cases in the accident on her behalf to take the necessary action. A few days later, she really was sent to the Guangzhou Baiyun family mental hospital, 5 days in custody, she was transferred to the lake ports, Zhongshan Hospital, imprisoned for three months.
after she got home, but also by the mother under house arrest. More than a month later, she escaped to seek refuge with friends and finally driven out of home, never go back.
earlier statements, however Zou people, but the opposite. October 2007, Zou Yijun family mental hospital in Guangzhou Baiyun held a press conference, read out up to 8-page open letter. The letter said, Zou should have because his father died and failed marriage, a double blow, there were 8 suicide, has been suffering from mental illness, they have done, are good for her.
and Zou admitted to psychiatric hospitals should have in the time taken to her family, saying the letter. Guangzhou Baiyun still do not believe in mental hospitals a financial incentive to say,
insiders said Zou Zou Yi people were sent to psychiatric hospitals into the novelty factor. Zou should have converted the end of 2005, they began enthusiastic about public welfare, her mother found her changed, she felt her daughter,
contradictions in the quarrel broke out day after day. October 2006, Zou were taken to a psychiatric hospital should be compulsory treatment, Chow's brother and mother asked the hospital to cut off her contact with the outside world. After consultation, the Guangzhou Baiyun psychological hospital treated Zou Yijun, in its view, Zou Yijun
but the They instinctively hospital and Zou people doubt the motive of trying to
. She believes that mental hospital is a form of
is it?
understand the words, does not become a subject of. in the
mental hospital several times according to the Guangzhou Baiyun the results of consultation, Zou Yi are suffering from a Medical records on the record rash and there was a history of depression, currently manic without psychotic symptoms. entangled by such diseases, the disease, also known as bipolar disorder, is a both manic, hypomanic and depressive episodes of affective disorder.
Guangzhou Baiyun Mental Hospital Zoulin Feng, Marketing Manager, said: did not point this at home, family shame should not do, but she will not hide the truth, and with the 'Cultural Revolution' as when the report came to light. According to the CDC in early 2009 the Chinese Ministry of Health statistics, China has psychological problems and mental illness, the total population of over 100 million.
the hospital that Chow should have the most serious problem is that there is no insight. Yen-Chi has been the patient meal to beat, but also experienced a seemingly normal patients to cut down the nets, one by one curtain rod to hang in an attempt to hang himself. Over time the Zou Yijun
of light that can be heavy, and repeatedly
the spirit of the medical profession in China, many of hospitalization of mental patients the right to have reservations about. They believe that as a serious condition and complete loss of cognitive ability of mental patients can not exercise the right hospital. The mental patient refused hospitalization, not out of reason. If we allow mental patients refuse hospitalization, may make them delaying treatment, his condition worsened.
hospital-based family dispute that would be normal with the inquiry into the mental hospital is Twenty years in the Yen-Chi medical career, had only found one case similar to the event: A family in Hunan girls were taken to hospital for treatment malicious, but the hospital was told the girl, she did not sick. This exclusion, But the hospital insisted that all consultation should be repeated as the results of Zou,UGG boots,
Zou with the media and the community should have the sympathy of the contrary, the hospital should have taken the letter of the Zou's family. make life difficult? her family tortured her cruelly.
No comments:
Post a Comment